• 3 Posts
  • 530 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 5th, 2023

help-circle

  • Which tax advantaged account doesn’t matter to growth or liquidity.
    For growth, what matters is what you’re holding in the accounts.
    And you can’t take any of it out until retirement, so viscosity doesn’t even matter much.

    Beyond that answering your question would require knowing the current distribution.

    In short I think you’re confidently looking at this the wrong way and need to talk to a professional to get things straightened out.













  • The purpose is what I stated.

    I never said purpose. You did. Originally I said “the point of insurance”.

    What you describe is no different than two people making a bet. Making a bet isn’t insurance.

    Insurance is different only because of the large organization on the other side making countless bets at scale.

    It’s almost as though you’re refusing to consider the larger context, because:

    Nobody “knows” how much insurance is worth. Insurance companies pay lots of money to obtain data and make calculations about predictions.

    My claim was predicted on nobody else in the world wanting insurance. Insurance companies wouldn’t exist. The concept of Insurance wouldn’t exist. That research and data wouldn’t be done. For that first person and whoever is on the other side, it’s still just a bet.

    See what I mean. You’re leaving out the larger context.





  • All of that is about a company selling a product in a market.

    But insurance doesn’t need to be that. It’s purpose is unrelated to any of that.

    Insurance, no matter where it comes from, is about pooling money from a large group to cover the losses of a small group. It exists because nobody knows which group they’ll be in.

    EDIT:
    Ideally insurance would be a state regulated monopoly, in order to have the largest possible pool. That would be the most effective and efficient way of doing it.

    In fact trying to categorize people into lower and higher risk pools, just makes smaller pools. Which hurts the overall efficiency of insurance for the purpose of creating more attractive products to sell in a profit driven market. It’s an example of how commerce itself can actually hurt some markets.

    What you describe as an individual spreading out small payments instead of having one large payment, is actually just a loan. You can open a line of credit at a bank for emergencies. That does the same thing. It isn’t insurance.