Indeed I did. I had apparently screwed up the formatting of a couple of the entries. The associated apps worked on a daily basis, the certificate was visible, but apparently the improper formatting was enough to confuse Caddy when it came to renewing the cert. Looking at the backup Caddyfile verses the newly formatted Caddyfile, I had a couple braces out of whack.
ETA: what led to all of this was that two certs expired today, and everything I had previously read said that Caddy wouldn’t let that happen. Well it won’t if I don’t fatfinger the format next time
Absolutely, and now I know a little more about the process.
It’s been a good day 'tater.