If you roleplay or do fanfic or write any story—original or some fanfic of an already existing story—the dialogue sounds awful, and that’s true for every AI: ChatGPT, Claude, Grok, etc. Mainly, the dialogue is unbelievably repetitive, and then characters either have an overreaction to something or an underreaction to something. The dialogue sounds truly, truly awful. No one really has a distinct personality; they all sound the same, repeat the same lines, and the dialogue is cringelord-tier. It doesn’t sound like real, actual people talking.
Why does a robot act like a robot?
Because all of the funding is going towards making them more competent at following instructions and not being offensive to corporate sensibilities, and making an AI model good at those things makes it worse at producing creatively interesting text. There are models that are attempts at retraining to be better at that, with limited success. I think there just aren’t a lot of resources being devoted to improving this area.
It doesn’t sound like real actual people talking because it’s not real actual people talking.
Try something for me. Type a sentence, any sentence, on your phone. Then mash the middle suggested next word button about fifty times.
Congratulations, you’re an AI! Well, that’s a very simplified version of what generative AI does, it takes your text and then predicts the likely “next” text again and again until it either runs out of room or predicts “text ends here”. Yes there’s some preamble, and it’s not using the same dictionary, and it’s not predicting word-by-word but token-by-token, and there’s some randomness thrown in for spice, but that’s about the size of it.
When you’re texting, do you ever type a word rather than selecting the middle word? Or even the top three? That’s the fundamental reason why LLMs don’t talk like humans. They literally cannot do that.
the dialogue sounds awful
The dialogue sounds truly, truly awful
the dialogue is unbelievably repetitive
repeat the same lines
🤔
Because it was written by a hack based on a prompt written by someone who isn’t a writer.
Because it’s not a dialogue, it’s a random word generator.
Why are you using AI if you have no idea what it is and what it does? Do you use a hammer to cook your pasta and then wonder why it’s not working?
Smashed pasta, now that’s a new meal to try
LLMs build plausible-sounding texts. They don’t have to be correct or even good.
Think of it this way: If you take all of the dialogue in digital and print media (include forum flame wars, cheap romance novels, and fanfics) then try to get an average out of that - what do you get?
It was the best of times, it was the blurst of times
deleted by creator
If you’re dealing with an LLM, which you most likely are, the AI will adapt based upon what words and scenarios you use. It can’t readily know what you’re aiming for and what characters you’re using to treat them as individual entities in whatever the RP is. You have to do an awful lot of heavy lifting to get to the point of the AI to grasp what you want out of it.
That’s just how it is.
LLMs aren’t capable of doing any better. The only reason you or anyone might think they are is because of aggressive
marketinggrifting by the very few people in a position to profit by convincing the world LLMs are basically the main ship computer from Star Trek when in fact they’re more like ELIZA.Ironic.
That second last sentence is just describing yourself:
- No distinct personality
- Repeat the same lines
- Dialogue is cringe lord tier
- You don’t sound like a real person
Maybe you should write your own fucking stories instead of trying to get an unintelligent machine to write it for you. You know what you want the characters to say and do
Because it’s trained by reading things on the internet and some of what it reads is stupid
Because it hasn’t been trained on significant amounts of dialogue as a primary source for speech patterns. It also isn’t meant to be distinct unless the instructions make it distinct.
Because it’s stupid and should be avoided at all costs.
