(Apologies for my tone below, but this affects me also, and I dislike the notion that messing with how you normally select text is a niche desire)
We don’t need any new functionality or a custom mode, we just want unexpected popups to not get in the way of expected behaviour when selecting text.
As long as your options appear well above the text, and doesn’t cancel the highlighting, I can’t accept whatever you want to do. But as the OP writes, if it’s easy to misclick, this is bad UI design because it does not conform to the expectation that nothing will pop up. (Google Docs is the first example that comes to mind as implementing popup options totally fine, from recollection)
If it’s too close to the selected text and causes misclicks, then I’m gonna be annoyed about this since the vast, vast majority (luckily) of text on the internet you can highlight to your heart’s content and nothing pops up.
Just keep options decently above the highlighted text (I dunno what the right number is, 2 lines above the start of your selection? hey I’m not a UI designer)
In conclusion, change is okay, but intuition is important.
Tantacrul makes some great UI videos if you haven’t seen them before (not that I’m telling you how to suck eggs about your own profession, he’s just genuinely funny and interesting to watch)
(Apologies for my tone below, but this affects me also, and I dislike the notion that messing with how you normally select text is a niche desire)
We don’t need any new functionality or a custom mode, we just want unexpected popups to not get in the way of expected behaviour when selecting text.
As long as your options appear well above the text, and doesn’t cancel the highlighting, I can’t accept whatever you want to do. But as the OP writes, if it’s easy to misclick, this is bad UI design because it does not conform to the expectation that nothing will pop up. (Google Docs is the first example that comes to mind as implementing popup options totally fine, from recollection)
If it’s too close to the selected text and causes misclicks, then I’m gonna be annoyed about this since the vast, vast majority (luckily) of text on the internet you can highlight to your heart’s content and nothing pops up.
Just keep options decently above the highlighted text (I dunno what the right number is, 2 lines above the start of your selection? hey I’m not a UI designer)
In conclusion, change is okay, but intuition is important.
Tantacrul makes some great UI videos if you haven’t seen them before (not that I’m telling you how to suck eggs about your own profession, he’s just genuinely funny and interesting to watch)